Man of Steel (2013)

All non-Nolan related film, tv, and streaming discussions.
Posts: 534
Joined: November 2013
Location: Earth*
No it is official he is done.

Posts: 3
Joined: January 2014
Poor choice, I just don't see him pulling it off but in the past choices initially thought of as poor worked out and were great (Heath Ledger as Joker). As of right now I just cannot see him pulling off Lex Luthor.

Posts: 18973
Joined: June 2012
Location: 1500s England
I'm not a fan of Eisenberg. And I really hope he won't play Lex like most of his roles. As for his look, I think bald would look good on him. As for his age, I like it that he's the same age as Cavill. Just like BaleBatman/LedgerJoker, it's interesting to have the main hero and villain to be around the same age. I know age didn't play out that huge in TDK but it was there. Joker wasn't a whole lot younger nor a whole lot older. And I like that Lex will be around Supes' age. Although, Eisenberg can easily fit for a younger version, he can make that convincing as well.

For the totality, I just hope Lex is a well written character. We haven't seen the definitive version of Lex Luthor on screen before (sorry Hackman/Spacey) and it's about them we get that. I think he's the best Superman villain and a very interesting character.

But I remain skeptical about Eisenberg as Lex until we get some concrete footage, unfortunately that's gonna take a while. Hopefully we'll hear Eisenberg himself about the casting soon, I'd be interested to hear what he has to say about it.

Posts: 18973
Joined: June 2012
Location: 1500s England
I give MOS a 8/10

Posts: 6
Joined: February 2014
I think people that were expecting the light heart hero from the Christopher Reeve movie were probably the ones that had the least kind things to say about the movie. Keeping a "first contact" kind of theme throughout the movie seemed more realistic than brushing off the fact that Clark is from another planet, like how Lois did in the old Superman movie. I mean she's an award winning reporter, isn't that something you would really drill an alien from another world about? The only bad things I didn't like about the movie is the fact that Superman carelessly destroyed a lot of his hometown and Metropolis. I mean, they were there for him and the codex and Zod just wanted to kill him towards the end right? So why didn't he just lure the bad guys into a corn field or something? But the fights were cool, so whatever. :X

Posts: 1997
Joined: July 2012
Location: Boston, MA

Generous. I was about to give it a 5.

12 yearz got me thinking about my favorite mcqueen scenes.

their dinner conversation + this =

Posts: 3643
Joined: January 2011
Location: Stuck in the lounge area
You are a Canadian treasure solo.

i know you are but what am I?

Posts: 163
Joined: November 2009
I'm a little late to the party, sorry about that. I've run the gamut on my feelings on this film, and I think I've come around fully on it, back right where I started.

A nice modernization of the Superman legend, and I quite liked it, despite it's many, many flaws. I'll keep my perspective on things in the realm of Nolan's supposed influence, because this is a Nolan board after all. It's not fully obvious which parts of the story are Nolan/Goyer's to me, but I could feel his influence at parts. I'm not a very big Zack Snyder fan, but I do like some of his movies. I thought this film was his best to date, mostly because it didn't feel like a typical Zack Snyder movie to me. Certainly, it's his finest directing job so far.

What struck me the most was the effective use of emotion. Nolan, to me, is not viscerally emotional, if that makes sense. Any emotion you sense, is almost all subtext. He seems to require you to buy in to what he's selling for you to get it. He doesn't use camera tricks and music to make you get emotional (see Peter Jackson and Lord of the Rings final chapter for that). I much prefer Nolan's approach, even though it doesn't always work for me. When I think about some specific scenes in The Prestige and the scene in Batman Begins when Alfred comforts adolescent Bruce... it's almost 100% the actors and the dialogue that pull it off. It just feels real in those instances, and I bought in fully. To be fair, I think Man of Steel falls in between those two styles... and for me it's the relationship between father and son / mother and son. So much of that is just personal experience... I had a red cape as a kid, used to run around and play Superman, so there's your buy in. As a parent with a two year old and a very serious thought about the job I have to do in raising my son, the very thought of the Kents' roll in shaping Clark's outlook and values really resonates with me. I bought in before I ever entered the theater, so I got choked up in many of the scenes. Clark's Mom calming him down by telling him to focus on her voice.. Pa Kent not hesitating to tell Clark that he is his son, no matter what. The absurdity at Jonathan Kent's death got a pass because I got what they were trying to do, and just not wanting him to die. But that final scene of him watching his son play in that red cape brought me to tears. That scene is just beautiful.

So, I love this film for some very personal reasons. I get the problems very clearly, many of which are described above. No need for me to rehash them as complaints here. Bottom line is I think the good and great parts of the film outweigh the bad and I want to see more of this Superman. I'm a little bummed that we aren't getting a true Superman sequel. Cavill was great in the role.

The only thing I outright hated was the cinematography. I think they could have done something that wasn't so washed out and bland looking. not saying it needed to be a bright look exactly.. but it just looked unrealistic, with everyone's flesh tones looking artificial.... particularly the Earthbound scenes.

Post Reply