Search found 11 matches

by tadpole25
Forum: The Dark Knight Rises
Topic: Could TDKR have forgone combat completely?
Replies: 2
Views: 2838

Could TDKR have forgone combat completely?

Applaudable is Nolan's effort to make a movie that doesn't reply on fist strikes and gun shots to make it's most powerful moments, yet there are still numerous combat bits (less than TDK) though. Do you think that TDKR's absence of Batman in action, pummeling his foes in the ground and narrowly esca...
by tadpole25
Forum: The Dark Knight Rises
Topic: NF Reviews/Reactions Only
Replies: 663
Views: 132508

Re: NF Reviews/Reactions Only

The Dark Knight Rises 8/10 "The Dark Knight Rises lacks the shine and polish that it's predecessor has, but it rises above it's frustration with a grim life-affirming story and a convoluted take on morality that makes it compelling in it's own right." With the immense success of TDK, TKDR was given...
by tadpole25
Forum: The Dark Knight Rises
Topic: Just watched TDKR. Deep, fascinating disappointment.
Replies: 1
Views: 2878

Just watched TDKR. Deep, fascinating disappointment.

With the immense success of TDK, TKDR was given a gold standard that most films probably couldn't have met. TKDR does have the framework, but doesn't come together as well as it's predecessor did. Lots of critics have called it dark, murky and dull. One even saying "why so serious". It's a superhero...
by tadpole25
Forum: The Dark Knight
Topic: Criticisms of The Dark Knight?
Replies: 3
Views: 3376

Criticisms of The Dark Knight?

I'm not saying this movie is perfect and completely free of flaw - no movie is. But there are no significant or meaningful flaws. Any flaws from this film are just nitpicks.
by tadpole25
Forum: The Dark Knight
Topic: Can anyone explain the ferry scene?
Replies: 13
Views: 33289

Can anyone explain the ferry scene?

To the above poster, I would not completely rule out the fact that one boat has prisoners on it as an irrelevant factor. It gave the non-prisoner ferry a greater incentive to CONSIDER blowing up the other boat. They did at least vote on it, even if they didn't detonate it. If the other boat were ful...
by tadpole25
Forum: The Dark Knight
Topic: Who wins?
Replies: 34
Views: 9697

Who wins?

I'm going to give an answer that goes a little against the grain of what everyone else wrote: Batman won. But his victory was Pyrrhic (meaning he won, but at a huge cost). Think of the Civil War, when General Lee would lose certain battles, but weaken Grant's forced by attrition, overall giving the ...
by tadpole25
Forum: The Dark Knight
Topic: CGI Two-Face...Why?
Replies: 49
Views: 16821

CGI Two-Face...Why?

Uncanny valley. The point was to make the CGI look as dramatized as possible. If the wounds looked realisitic, people would be offended the whole film.
by tadpole25
Forum: The Dark Knight
Topic: Can anyone explain the ferry scene?
Replies: 13
Views: 33289

Can anyone explain the ferry scene?

There's nothing to suggest that the passengers on either boat doubted Joker's threat.

The point is that the most logical decision is not always the easiest decision to make emotionally.
by tadpole25
Forum: The Dark Knight
Topic: Harvey Dent Was Murdered?
Replies: 51
Views: 15832

Harvey Dent Was Murdered?

Technically yes it was murder (manslaughter), but in context, I don't think he violated his principles. This was [technically] murder because it was direct. People who died indirectly don't count. Occam's razor would make that hard to calculate. But 1. It was unintentional 2. There was no other opti...
by tadpole25
Forum: The Dark Knight
Topic: Is the joker a sane man?
Replies: 58
Views: 15035

Is the joker a sane man?

Joker is nihilistic, sociopathic, malicious, sadistic, but not insane (unlike the people are working for him).

Sanity involves perception of reality.