I'm a John G wrote:oh wait! i have another question regarding this. don't care that i double posted.Aili wrote:Sky007 wrote:Okay let's get talking!Thoughts on the final moments with Cooper leaving to find Brand on the planet?For that bit, Brand seemed to be on Edwards, and it looked livable, there were houses around and she seemed to be tending a grave (of her dead lover?)
I thought it was obvious when Coop leaves Brand to go in the black hole and they look back at each other, they both sort of suddenly realize they love each other but were too professional and too uptight to ever admit it.
How Old Murph KNEW Brand was still out there and alone (or mostly alone), I don't know!
why hasn't Brand aged more on Edmunds' planet?? we know Coop hasn't aged because he was trapped in the tesseract, and while he was there + doing the mission Earth essentially aged like 90 years. but a significant portion of those 90 years must have been when he was in the tesseract, so why hasn't Brand aged on the planet? he doesn't reach her until at least 40+ years of Earth time passing since falling into the tesseract, since Murph is so old when he's spit out. she figures out the equation, the tesseract closes, Coop is spit out, and they find him when Murph is on her deathbed....
...so then how is Brand still young, sexy Anne Hathaway at the end? wouldn't she be closer to Murphs age?
unless, of course, that last shot of Brand wasn't meant to be a 'present' shot, and she actually did age and we just didn't see it...
Coop got spit out hours after he entered the black hole. Remember the doctor telling him that he was lucky they found him when he did because he only had a few minutes left of oxygen. So Coop returned only hours after he left Brand. I think the 90 earth years passing happened when they were trying to sling shot the black hole. Brand probably did age more than Coop did but not by much.