Search found 26260 matches

by Cilogy
Forum: Inception
Topic: IMDB 250 ?
Replies: 19
Views: 2853

Re: IMDB 250 ?

I'll be honest, I always thought IMDb fanboys were much harsher than RT or Metacritic, this rating on IMDb has really surprised me. The reason TDK has so many votes is because lovers of Shawshank and the Godfather voted it down to "keep it below the top 5" in a sense. But I have not seen this lunacy...
by Cilogy
Forum: Inception
Topic: Inception Review Discussion (240 total)
Replies: 3024
Views: 271871

Re: Inception Review Discussion (233 total)

Hopefully, again, Nolan will save another superhero.
by Cilogy
Forum: Inception
Topic: User Podcast Review: Inception -- JPRaup
Replies: 15
Views: 2185

Re: User Podcast Review: Inception -- JPRaup

jpraup wrote:as promised, my SPOILER-FREE text review:

[Review] 'Inception' Keeps The Dream Alive - http://thefilmstage.com/Eg

10 out of 10
F*ck you, you lucky bastard ...

:JGLface:

Seriously, thanks, this was a great review. :thumbup:
by Cilogy
Forum: Inception
Topic: Inception Review Discussion (240 total)
Replies: 3024
Views: 271871

Re: Inception Review Discussion (233 total)

RT and Metacritic aren't everything, look at the first page of this thread and all of the reviews that aren't counted to either site and the picture is still overwhelmingly positive. Yeah but I still want Inception to do well financially, so Nolan can keep turning out his own milk instead of buying...
by Cilogy
Forum: Inception
Topic: Inception Review Discussion (240 total)
Replies: 3024
Views: 271871

Re: Inception Review Discussion (233 total)

jake088800 wrote:
Christopher Nolan wrote:
redfirebird2008 wrote:
Again I say, who gives a crap? The Prestige was and is a better film than The Departed for me and it's only been made more obvious with repeat viewings over the years.
the departed is overrated..
How can The Departed be overrated?
If its ratings are over-the-top or excessive.
by Cilogy
Forum: Inception
Topic: Inception Review Discussion (240 total)
Replies: 3024
Views: 271871

Re: Inception Review Discussion (233 total)

Christopher Nolan wrote:cant believe avatar got 84 %....

inception will have 40 critics on metacritic? am i right, if so, chances are good to reach 82%..
There aren't enough critics that like movies that (god help us) make you think.
by Cilogy
Forum: Inception
Topic: **ROGER EBERT*** 4/4!!!
Replies: 41
Views: 4320

Re: **ROGER EBERT*** 4/4!!!

Have you guys actually SEEN Eclipse?
by Cilogy
Forum: Inception
Topic: Inception Review Discussion (240 total)
Replies: 3024
Views: 271871

Re: Inception Review Discussion (233 total)

redfirebird2008 wrote:
George wrote:New York Times was posted as an 80, brining Inception up to a 76 :thumbup:
Woah, shocking disparity between RT and Meta on Scott's review. One gives it a 50/100 and the other gives it a 80/100. :lol:
That's why nothing on Metacritic makes sense anymore.
by Cilogy
Forum: Inception
Topic: 87% on RT
Replies: 422
Views: 36516

Re: 87% on RT

Now at 85%

:JGLface:
by Cilogy
Forum: Inception
Topic: Inception Review Discussion (240 total)
Replies: 3024
Views: 271871

Re: Inception Review Discussion (233 total)

I (who wasn't crazy about dark knight but loved momento) think that one reason folks are concerned about bad reviews, even given the (partial) subjectivity of preference, is that this is an explicitly risky intelligent movie and those critics who casually blow it off and support something like the ...