Christopher Nolan Fans
Christopher Nolan Fans

Animal Cruelty

A place for more serious off-topic discussion and debates.

Animal Cruelty

Post Mason April 21, 2012, 1:26 pm

PETA is just one big conspiracy. Look up the truth.
Mason None specified
A Legend
A Legend
 
Posts: 18356
Joined: February 2011

Animal Cruelty

Post RIFA April 21, 2012, 1:35 pm

Pratham wrote:
RIFA wrote:Vegetarianism is some 18th century invention. Medically, vegetarianism is not healthy at all. But keep on dreaming it is.


What?
What about Buddhists, Jains, and some Hindus like brahmins (some people in these religions/castes eat meat, buy majority is still vegan.)



they eat meat. some eat fish for example. they don't eat various types of meat that's something else. And yes, vegetarians existed before as in individuals. I was referring to "vegetarianism" as in the cult itself.
SilverHeart wrote:Wait, Gorbachev isn't dead?

April 6, 2013
User avatar
RIFA Male
A Legend
A Legend
 
Posts: 12985
Joined: June 2010
Location: Bucharest

Animal Cruelty

Post Pratham April 21, 2012, 1:44 pm

RIFA wrote:
Pratham wrote:
What?
What about Buddhists, Jains, and some Hindus like brahmins (some people in these religions/castes eat meat, buy majority is still vegan.)



they eat meat. some eat fish for example. they don't eat various types of meat that's something else. And yes, vegetarians existed before as in individuals. I was referring to "vegetarianism" as in the cult itself.

Oh... fads in western countries. So, what are your views on people who are vegans for centuries as part of their religion?
Image
Image
User avatar
Pratham Male
Spam Hunter
Spam Hunter
 
Posts: 3750
Joined: May 2010
Location: Mumbai,India

Animal Cruelty

Post Cilogy April 21, 2012, 1:49 pm

Pratham wrote:
RIFA wrote:
they eat meat. some eat fish for example. they don't eat various types of meat that's something else. And yes, vegetarians existed before as in individuals. I was referring to "vegetarianism" as in the cult itself.

Oh... fads in western countries. So, what are your views on people who are vegans for centuries as part of their religion?

I don't think that's excusable as a reason. I mean, you still have nutritional issues with that. It's fighting against nature; we are biologically inclined to consume other animal organisms. People can do that if they choose, but it's definitely not optimal.

People of the Jain faith are not only non-meat eaters, but they also cannot eat things grown underground (potatoes, roots, etc.), and I believe they have some other food restrictions that would make it pretty difficult to live in modern times.
User avatar
Cilogy None specified
Opinionated Lion
Opinionated Lion
 
Posts: 10939
Joined: February 2010
Location: Ark 'n' Saw

Animal Cruelty

Post RIFA April 21, 2012, 1:49 pm

Pratham wrote:
RIFA wrote:
they eat meat. some eat fish for example. they don't eat various types of meat that's something else. And yes, vegetarians existed before as in individuals. I was referring to "vegetarianism" as in the cult itself.

Oh... fads in western countries. So, what are your views on people who are vegans for centuries as part of their religion?


My view is simple. It's all bullshit and pretentious.

Vegans usually fight nature.

And... to be honest... let's go even deeper and think if being a vegan isn't hypocritical when complaining that animals are tortured.

Plants are not lifeless. Just because you can't see the micro-organisms means that you're so superior you can BURN them do death? How is torturing a micro-organism different? Yes. It's a difference in size, shape... but it's not a difference in the process or result.

I don't wanna go there because I'll pull a Vader...
SilverHeart wrote:Wait, Gorbachev isn't dead?

April 6, 2013
User avatar
RIFA Male
A Legend
A Legend
 
Posts: 12985
Joined: June 2010
Location: Bucharest

Animal Cruelty

Post steveportee April 21, 2012, 1:52 pm

RIFA wrote:
Pratham wrote:Oh... fads in western countries. So, what are your views on people who are vegans for centuries as part of their religion?


My view is simple. It's all bullshit and pretentious.

Vegans usually fight nature.

And... to be honest... let's go even deeper and think if being a vegan isn't hypocritical when complaining that animals are tortured.

Plants are not lifeless. Just because you can't see the micro-organisms means that you're so superior you can BURN them do death? How is torturing a micro-organism different? Yes. It's a difference in size, shape... but it's not a difference in the process or result.

I don't wanna go there because I'll pull a Vader...

Plants don't have a central nervous system/brain.
"Steve is a true gentleman and a scholar." - Stephen Baldwin
User avatar
steveportee Male
A Legend
A Legend
 
Posts: 9047
Joined: July 2010

Animal Cruelty

Post Cilogy April 21, 2012, 1:54 pm

steveportee wrote:
RIFA wrote:
My view is simple. It's all bullshit and pretentious.

Vegans usually fight nature.

And... to be honest... let's go even deeper and think if being a vegan isn't hypocritical when complaining that animals are tortured.

Plants are not lifeless. Just because you can't see the micro-organisms means that you're so superior you can BURN them do death? How is torturing a micro-organism different? Yes. It's a difference in size, shape... but it's not a difference in the process or result.

I don't wanna go there because I'll pull a Vader...

Plants don't have a central nervous system/brain.

So that's the defining factor for what we should eat and shouldn't eat?
User avatar
Cilogy None specified
Opinionated Lion
Opinionated Lion
 
Posts: 10939
Joined: February 2010
Location: Ark 'n' Saw

Animal Cruelty

Post steveportee April 21, 2012, 1:55 pm

Cilogy wrote:
steveportee wrote:Plants don't have a central nervous system/brain.

So that's the defining factor for what we should eat and shouldn't eat?

It's the defining factor for whether or not they can feel pain.
"Steve is a true gentleman and a scholar." - Stephen Baldwin
User avatar
steveportee Male
A Legend
A Legend
 
Posts: 9047
Joined: July 2010

Animal Cruelty

Post Pratham April 21, 2012, 1:56 pm

Cilogy, just out of curiosity, do you eat beef/pork?
I haven't, and have no desire either.
Image
Image
User avatar
Pratham Male
Spam Hunter
Spam Hunter
 
Posts: 3750
Joined: May 2010
Location: Mumbai,India

Animal Cruelty

Post RIFA April 21, 2012, 1:57 pm

steveportee wrote:
RIFA wrote:
My view is simple. It's all bullshit and pretentious.

Vegans usually fight nature.

And... to be honest... let's go even deeper and think if being a vegan isn't hypocritical when complaining that animals are tortured.

Plants are not lifeless. Just because you can't see the micro-organisms means that you're so superior you can BURN them do death? How is torturing a micro-organism different? Yes. It's a difference in size, shape... but it's not a difference in the process or result.

I don't wanna go there because I'll pull a Vader...

Plants don't have a central nervous system/brain.


Single celled organisms have no central nervous system but not all plants and everything a vegan would eat is formed only out of single celled organisms.

Not to mention that they are still living... But to use another perspective...

How about ants or insects that you squash them under your feet in the summer or when they invade your desk? I want to see that vegan that never squashed a bug because it was annoying and he squashed it so badly the bug was still alive and crawling to his death...
SilverHeart wrote:Wait, Gorbachev isn't dead?

April 6, 2013
User avatar
RIFA Male
A Legend
A Legend
 
Posts: 12985
Joined: June 2010
Location: Bucharest

PreviousNext


Return to World Affairs & Philosophy

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest