Favorite portrayal of Murph

Christopher Nolan's 2014 grand scale science-fiction story about time and space, and the things that transcend them.
User avatar
Posts: 26396
Joined: February 2010
Location: Houston, Texas
all three did pretty damn fantastic jobs

each one made me cry, but I think I feel like if Foy couldn't sell the role as well as she did, then Chastain and Burstyn wouldn't have been able to bring it home

User avatar
Posts: 1016
Joined: April 2013
Chastain obviously.

User avatar
Posts: 43129
Joined: May 2010
MeLVaNoaTe wrote:Chastain obviously.
How is it obvious? :lol: Everyone picked Foy so far.

User avatar
Posts: 604
Joined: December 2012
Location: The Endurance
This is really hard to pick. But I'll go with Foy.

Posts: 836
Joined: January 2014
Mackenzie Foy was after McC the best performance in Interstellar. You totally believed their relationship and how much they loved each other. Cause if you didn't, the rest of the movie wouldn't make sense.

Ellen Burstyn was fantastic in that last scene, but also in the recorded messages in the Dust Bowl segment. When Coop says to her 'You told them I liked farming?' and her whole face explodes in joy, it was so great. And of course her line 'because my dad promised me' is such a killer.

I think Jessica had the hardest bit because she couldn't interact with McC, so she couldn't display the warmth and total love Mackenzie and Ellen could. But she was so amazing in the recording that McC watches and the audience can totally believe she would cause so much pain to her father that he would totally break down. Jessica's Murph was mainly animated by resentment and bitterness, so that's hard to make sympathetic but she still succeeded.

It's a sign of what great actresses all three are that the segues from one Murph to the other never felt awkward. The Tesseract scene where there's a sort of dance between Mackenzie and Jessica and McC was beautifully done.

User avatar
Posts: 1016
Joined: April 2013
Allstar wrote:
MeLVaNoaTe wrote:Chastain obviously.
How is it obvious? :lol: Everyone picked Foy so far.
Well, the few Foy fanboys who have voted for her here is nothing compared to the general public consensus that Chastain's was the standout female performance.
Honestly, Foy was not even good.

User avatar
Posts: 4288
Joined: May 2014
Location: “Where are you?!” “HERE.”
MeLVaNoaTe wrote:
Allstar wrote:
MeLVaNoaTe wrote:Chastain obviously.
How is it obvious? :lol: Everyone picked Foy so far.
Well, the few Foy fanboys who have voted for her here is nothing compared to the general public consensus that Chastain's was the standout female performance.
Honestly, Foy was not even good.
LOL

User avatar
Posts: 26396
Joined: February 2010
Location: Houston, Texas
MeLVaNoaTe wrote:
Allstar wrote:
MeLVaNoaTe wrote:Chastain obviously.
How is it obvious? :lol: Everyone picked Foy so far.
Well, the few Foy fanboys who have voted for her here is nothing compared to the general public consensus that Chastain's was the standout female performance.
Honestly, Foy was not even good.
I'm gonna sound like a completely blind fanboy, but considering this and other posts, why are you here?

User avatar
Posts: 604
Joined: December 2012
Location: The Endurance
MeLVaNoaTe wrote:
Allstar wrote:
MeLVaNoaTe wrote:Chastain obviously.
How is it obvious? :lol: Everyone picked Foy so far.
Well, the few Foy fanboys who have voted for her here is nothing compared to the general public consensus that Chastain's was the standout female performance.
Honestly, Foy was not even good.
As far as I know, the general audience (outside NF) mostly agreed that Foy's was the best female performance in the film.

Posts: 279
Joined: July 2014
MeLVaNoaTe wrote:
Allstar wrote:
MeLVaNoaTe wrote:Chastain obviously.
How is it obvious? :lol: Everyone picked Foy so far.
Well, the few Foy fanboys who have voted for her here is nothing compared to the general public consensus that Chastain's was the standout female performance.
Honestly, Foy was not even good.
"McConaughey has never been better, and Foy is devastatingly effective as a little girl who’s scary smart but still doesn’t understand why her father has to abandon her." -Richard Roeper

http://entertainment.suntimes.com/movie ... cts-ideas/

Post Reply