'Interstellar' Official Reviews
Posts: 836
Joined:
January 2014
Posts: 489
Joined:
December 2011
Dork Shelf
Negative
http://dorkshelf.com/2014/11/04/interstellar-review/
There’s an undeniable beauty to science fiction, and Christopher Nolan’s hotly anticipated futuristic epic Interstellar is a mostly beautiful thing to look at. Notice that I said, very specifically, “to look at,” because no matter how good it looks, it’s impossible to endorse a film that’s so silly and takes itself so seriously and at face value. It’s so goofball in its vaguely worded, Capra-esque sentimentality, and yet so po-faced in its relentless sermonizing to the audience that it forgets to be fun and thoughtful and settles for cloyingly manipulative, jingoistic, misguided, shockingly unoriginal, and sloppily plotted. It’s as thoroughly moronic and scientifically dunderheaded as Michael Bay’s Armageddon, but like that same material is being delivered with the swagger of a doctorate candidate that’s blissfully unaware that they’re going to fail their thesis defense.
Negative
http://dorkshelf.com/2014/11/04/interstellar-review/
There’s an undeniable beauty to science fiction, and Christopher Nolan’s hotly anticipated futuristic epic Interstellar is a mostly beautiful thing to look at. Notice that I said, very specifically, “to look at,” because no matter how good it looks, it’s impossible to endorse a film that’s so silly and takes itself so seriously and at face value. It’s so goofball in its vaguely worded, Capra-esque sentimentality, and yet so po-faced in its relentless sermonizing to the audience that it forgets to be fun and thoughtful and settles for cloyingly manipulative, jingoistic, misguided, shockingly unoriginal, and sloppily plotted. It’s as thoroughly moronic and scientifically dunderheaded as Michael Bay’s Armageddon, but like that same material is being delivered with the swagger of a doctorate candidate that’s blissfully unaware that they’re going to fail their thesis defense.
Posts: 279
Joined:
July 2014
Posts: 279
Joined:
July 2014
Deadspin: mixed-positive I think. Someone who wants to give it a proper read-through can comment:
http://theconcourse.deadspin.com/christ ... 1654519456
http://theconcourse.deadspin.com/christ ... 1654519456
Posts: 279
Joined:
July 2014
From Brazil
Positive 10/10
Um Tigre No Cinema (Tiago Lira)
http://umtigrenocinema.com/interestelar-critica/
Positive 10/10
Um Tigre No Cinema (Tiago Lira)
http://umtigrenocinema.com/interestelar-critica/
Posts: 279
Joined:
July 2014
Mixed-Positive. RT critic but posts are normally from the Seattle Times:
http://www.theolympian.com/2014/11/04/3 ... p=/99/988/
http://www.theolympian.com/2014/11/04/3 ... p=/99/988/
One of the top 5 worst critics from Brazil. Period.LeoCobb wrote:From Brazil
Pablo Villaça (Nagative)
"Disappointment". PS: He - normally - praises Nolan's films.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uXmk9vXbUIw
Concordo. Não gosto dele. A Ana Maria, apesar da história do Ben Affleck, manja muito de cinema. Ela nem gostou muito, nem desgostou (e ela é fã do Nolan também). Está bem estranho isso: críticos que não gostavam elogiando e outros que eram "fãs", decepcionados. Mesma coisa com o Rodrigo Salem da Folha.ek79 wrote:One of the top 5 worst critics from Brazil. Period.LeoCobb wrote:From Brazil
Pablo Villaça (Nagative)
"Disappointment". PS: He - normally - praises Nolan's films.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uXmk9vXbUIw
Posts: 836
Joined:
January 2014
I don't think this one is up yet. It's a rave.
http://www.radiotimes.com/news/2014-11- ... uman-heart
http://www.radiotimes.com/news/2014-11- ... uman-heart
