For me, it's the reverse order in which they were made:
1. TDKR
2. TDK
3. BB
1. TDKR - The final film just edges it for me because the spectacle is incredible. Everything comes together in this one; the acting, the stunts, the script, the characters, it's so rich.
2. TDK - Very close, but not quite for me. Overall, everything is great except I think it 'feels' very not batman. If you took away batman, it feels like a standard crime film (albeit an excellent one).
3. BB - The weakest in the trilogy I think, it still is a great film. I felt the villains were not so great, but I praise the design.
1. TDKR
2. TDK
3. BB
1. TDKR - The final film just edges it for me because the spectacle is incredible. Everything comes together in this one; the acting, the stunts, the script, the characters, it's so rich.
2. TDK - Very close, but not quite for me. Overall, everything is great except I think it 'feels' very not batman. If you took away batman, it feels like a standard crime film (albeit an excellent one).
3. BB - The weakest in the trilogy I think, it still is a great film. I felt the villains were not so great, but I praise the design.