out of the 12 negative review, give me 4 which are valid negative reviews other than Nolan hateRomanM wrote:These negative reviews are scary not because they're negative per se, but because they seem logical given the scope of the film and Chris's past films.
Inception Review Discussion (240 total)
Posts: 148
Joined:
July 2010
I'm not, its the posters before me that sounded down in the dumps. I still think its doing well and will get better ratings when its all said and done.redfirebird2008 wrote:What do you mean losing hope? The Prestige received a 75% rating overall and a 66 at MetaCritic. I think that film is brilliant and the critics were wrong. I do seriously doubt Inception has the character development of that film, which is disappointing but somewhat expected with a big budget action flick that has such a large ensemble cast.EctoCooler31 wrote:Isn't it a little early to start losing hope? I mean they have only posted 46 total reviews.
I hate to, but that score on RT makes me depressed that most of the positive reviews won't be posted?Eternalist wrote:People are overblowing this, the negative reviews are still far outweighed by the positive.
Posts: 32
Joined:
July 2010
3 out of 4. I believe.jhawkin1 wrote:was this 3 out of 5 stars ??
Posts: 148
Joined:
July 2010
no he gives it out of 4 startsjhawkin1 wrote:was this 3 out of 5 stars ??
Ironically he is a top critic and also gave Toy Story 3 stars
hasanbilal80 wrote:no he gives it out of 4 startsjhawkin1 wrote:was this 3 out of 5 stars ??
Ironically he is a top critic and also gave Toy Story 3 stars
Well then I am good to go! Lets go Ebert!!
Posts: 130
Joined:
July 2010
That sounds more like a mixed review than a negative one. He seems to have been slightly disappointed, but enjoyed it nonetheless.Inferno313 wrote:3 out of 4. I believe.jhawkin1 wrote:was this 3 out of 5 stars ??
He also gave Hot Tub Time Machine 3.5 out of 4hasanbilal80 wrote:no he gives it out of 4 startsjhawkin1 wrote:was this 3 out of 5 stars ??
Ironically he is a top critic and also gave Toy Story 3 stars
Posts: 81
Joined:
July 2010
No, Phillips like Ebert has a 4-star system. So it's 3/4, which would be positive on RT.jhawkin1 wrote:was this 3 out of 5 stars ??
I noticed that too, especially since the positive reviews noted how emotional it was.indy42 wrote:Which is partially what annoys me. Everybody two weeks ago was like, "Oh, well, since it's Christopher Nolan, it won't be emotional and will be mostly awesome visuals." Now, that's the exact criticism, like the critics are falling back on the faults they expected to find, as opposed to the faults actually there.RomanM wrote:These negative reviews are scary not because they're negative per se, but because they seem logical given the scope of the film and Chris's past films.
Nolan's right, ideas are like a virus - notice how some unnamed studio exec (I'm guessing he/she was from Sony) makes a comment that contradicts everything people have said about Nolan's character (most people find him a very warm and approachable person) and suddenly this 'cold' accusation is everywhere having previously never been mentioned? :JGLface:
Last edited by Bueller on July 14th, 2010, 2:02 pm, edited 1 time in total.
