Nolan's political views?

The Oscar Nominated writer and director to whom this site is dedicated.
Post Reply
Posts: 30
Joined: March 2012
What are they? Has he even talked about his political views before?

I guess you can sort of analyse and interpret TDK in hopes of answering this question, but it's still not very clear. The film acts as a sort of socio-political/philosophical discourse, without either overcoming the other.

Anyone have any ideas on what his political views are, and how it may affect the political themes in TDKR?

Posts: 15994
Joined: June 2011
Location: North Carolina
Oblong_Box wrote:What are they? Has he even talked about his political views before?

I guess you can sort of analyse and interpret TDK in hopes of answering this question, but it's still not very clear. The film acts as a sort of socio-political/philosophical discourse, without either overcoming the other.

Anyone have any ideas on what his political views are, and how it may affect the political themes in TDKR?
Wrong section wrong time

Posts: 30
Joined: March 2012
TehBatGetsBraked wrote:
Oblong_Box wrote:What are they? Has he even talked about his political views before?

I guess you can sort of analyse and interpret TDK in hopes of answering this question, but it's still not very clear. The film acts as a sort of socio-political/philosophical discourse, without either overcoming the other.

Anyone have any ideas on what his political views are, and how it may affect the political themes in TDKR?
Wrong section wrong time
Why?

Posts: 15994
Joined: June 2011
Location: North Carolina
Oblong_Box wrote:
TehBatGetsBraked wrote:
Wrong section wrong time
Why?
This would be in the thread "Nolan's Beliefs" and THE THIRD FUCKIN TRAILER is right around the corner.

Posts: 54164
Joined: May 2010
TehBatGetsBraked wrote:
Oblong_Box wrote:
Why?
This would be in the thread "Nolan's Beliefs" and THE THIRD FUCKIN TRAILER is right around the corner.
Amen. Close this n00b thread.

Posts: 30
Joined: March 2012
TehBatGetsBraked wrote:
Oblong_Box wrote:
Why?
This would be in the thread "Nolan's Beliefs" and THE THIRD FUCKIN TRAILER is right around the corner.
Did you not catch the part where I asked how it MAY AFFECT THE THEMES IN TDKR?

Posts: 54164
Joined: May 2010
Oblong_Box wrote:
TehBatGetsBraked wrote:
This would be in the thread "Nolan's Beliefs" and THE THIRD FUCKIN TRAILER is right around the corner.
Did you not catch the part where I asked how it MAY AFFECT THE THEMES IN TDKR?
Dude: http://www.nolanfans.com/forums/viewtop ... f=21&t=880

search engine next time ;)

Posts: 2980
Joined: June 2010
Nolan refrains from talking about his political or religious views, as far as I'm aware. He's stated in the past:
NOLAN: It’s funny, I’ve been asked a lot about the politics of the film. I dismiss all such analogies [laughs]. It really isn’t something we think about as we put the story together, myself, David Goyer and Jonathan [Nolan, brother of the director]. But I would point to the interrogation scene with Batman and the Joker — not that there is a specific political point, per se — but that I was interested in getting the actors to explore a paradox: How do you fight somebody who essentially thrives on aggression?

GB: I winced when I read a lot of the political messaging that people said they detected in your film. I think a lot of that says more about my industry than it does yours.

NOLAN: [Laughs] “Yes, you may be right.”

GB: It seems to me that, more often than not in a genre such as the one you’re working in, most of the political messaging has more to do with the viewer than the filmmaker. It’s inferred, not implied.

NOLAN: I agree completely. Especially if you do it right. If you’re working in a genre that is heightened reality. I like to talk about these films as having an operatic quality or being on a grand scale and a bit removed from the rhythms of real life, no matter how realistic we try to make the scenes themselves. In this scene, for instance, we went for the gritty realism in the textures of it, but it is a heightened reality. We’re trying to work on a more universal scale. If you get that right, people are going to be able to bring a wide variety of interpretations to it depending on who they are. It’s allowing the characters to be a conduit to the audience. Allowing an audience to sit there and relate to Batman and his dilemma whether they are Republican or Democrat or whatever.
http://herocomplex.latimes.com/2008/10/ ... opher-nol/

Posts: 30
Joined: March 2012
EnzoTheBaker wrote:Nolan refrains from talking about his political or religious views, as far as I'm aware. He's stated in the past:
NOLAN: It’s funny, I’ve been asked a lot about the politics of the film. I dismiss all such analogies [laughs]. It really isn’t something we think about as we put the story together, myself, David Goyer and Jonathan [Nolan, brother of the director]. But I would point to the interrogation scene with Batman and the Joker — not that there is a specific political point, per se — but that I was interested in getting the actors to explore a paradox: How do you fight somebody who essentially thrives on aggression?

GB: I winced when I read a lot of the political messaging that people said they detected in your film. I think a lot of that says more about my industry than it does yours.

NOLAN: [Laughs] “Yes, you may be right.”

GB: It seems to me that, more often than not in a genre such as the one you’re working in, most of the political messaging has more to do with the viewer than the filmmaker. It’s inferred, not implied.

NOLAN: I agree completely. Especially if you do it right. If you’re working in a genre that is heightened reality. I like to talk about these films as having an operatic quality or being on a grand scale and a bit removed from the rhythms of real life, no matter how realistic we try to make the scenes themselves. In this scene, for instance, we went for the gritty realism in the textures of it, but it is a heightened reality. We’re trying to work on a more universal scale. If you get that right, people are going to be able to bring a wide variety of interpretations to it depending on who they are. It’s allowing the characters to be a conduit to the audience. Allowing an audience to sit there and relate to Batman and his dilemma whether they are Republican or Democrat or whatever.
http://herocomplex.latimes.com/2008/10/ ... opher-nol/
That's basically what I was getting at in my original post. TDK works as a socio-political/philosophical discourse, where different ideas collide, and debate can be had. To say there is no political implications at all is rather surprising, because watching TDK is like attending a mini-seminar on socio-political theory 101. The Joker's monologues are literally political/philosophical rants on anarchism.

I'd just really like to know what Nolan's particular view is, because I'd like to predict on what political note he may end the series.

Posts: 4533
Joined: June 2011
Location: Lost Angeles
Liberal for sure.

Post Reply