Loading...
All non-Nolan related entertainment discussion. Join the fun!

Analysing Kubrick's Works

Posts: 7128
Location: London town, UK
I wrote my dissertation on 2001... i've done too much analysis of Kubrick.
Posts: 11709
Location: The White City
Rifa, I don't particularly think a lot of this is based on 'facts' the way you seem to be implying, he takes elements of the film and found extremely clever and effective ways to back them up with some facts about the movie. I don't think it's a leap from what most people do for most films, he just did it better, and is clearly well-researched and singular in what he brings to the table.

Still, I'd preferred him to comment specifically on other interpretations and so forth, since he seems to imply his interpretation means those are invalid (or at least unsatisfying), and my interpretation, and some of how the book ended, make a lot more objective sense than what he's arguing. (I.e. that going into the stargate is him literally passing through some form of inter-dimensional passageway outside the boundaries of space, time, and consciousness, and all the things he saw were merely planets, strange manifestations along the way, and very possibly other life forms. It may seem a bit simplistic and obvious, but his theory ignores a lot of these things, which made it a bit less effective than it may have been otherwise. Is that any clearer?


-Vader
Posts: 14633
Location: Bucharest
Vader182 wrote:Rifa, I don't particularly think a lot of this is based on 'facts' the way you seem to be implying, he takes elements of the film and found extremely clever and effective ways to back them up with some facts about the movie.


He talks about the Kubrick archives, and some other interviews and books released... most of the stuff he presents has a direct connection to Kubrick's words and ideas. That to me are facts.
Posts: 25579
Location: Interstellar/Gone Girl/Inherent Vice
Spatial awereness analysis of The Shining is truly amazing, you don't see that kind of film making approach these days, or not very often, to be fair.

My Kubrick list:


1. The Shining
2. 2001: A Space Odyssey
3. Clockwork Orange
4. Eyes Wide Shut
5. Dr. Strangelove
6. Lolita
7. Paths of Glory
8. Full Metal Jacket
9. Barry Lyndon
10. The Killing
← Previous page
← Return to Entertainment
Who is online