Depends on who's talking as always. You should be the judge. I believe the general rule here is a) if you hated theatrical you won't suddenly love UC (there's that one guy over at collider video though) and b) if you at least appreciated some aspects of theatrical cut you'll be more open to UC and react accordingly. At least now there's no mention of editing issues, except for the tacked on JL.wmv scene. Literally the only aspect that still sticks out right now, editing wise.
Despite numerous buildings being destroyed and falling, jet planes firing missiles and crashing, a gigantic alien spaceship hovering over Earth and Superman fighting with another alien.. The people in Wayne Enterprises needed permission to evacuate?
antovolk wrote:And here's a trailer I've been working on
This version is a vast improvement for me. Most of the primary characters benefit greatly, with Superman at the top of the list. I went from being almost completely indifferent to his presence in the third act to feeling sorry for the guy (and Lois). It plays like a Superman movie and, not that the bar was that high to begin with, this is the most compelling version of the character on screen so far.