Star Wars Universe Discussion Thread

All non-Nolan related entertainment discussion. Join the fun!
Posts: 26077
Joined: February 2010
Location: Tejas
ArmandFancypants wrote:
Cilogy wrote:
ArmandFancypants wrote:V
IV
VI
R1
III
I
II
VII
Who hurt you?
Larry Kasdan
Yeah

but

like

TFA at least has some semblance of a story

and logic

lol

Posts: 9733
Joined: October 2011
Location: Foot of Mt. Belzoni
It's a great con-job for sure.

Posts: 16715
Joined: March 2012
Okay even if you don't like VII there's no way it's worse than Clones and Phantom Menace. The fact that there's no blatant racial stereotypes alone puts it above those two.

Posts: 9733
Joined: October 2011
Location: Foot of Mt. Belzoni
SilverHeart wrote:Okay even if you don't like VII there's no way it's worse than Clones and Phantom Menace. The fact that there's no blatant racial stereotypes alone puts it above those two.
Cool, let me revise:

I
II
VII

Posts: 41948
Joined: May 2010
:blank:
ArmandFancypants wrote:
SilverHeart wrote:Okay even if you don't like VII there's no way it's worse than Clones and Phantom Menace. The fact that there's no blatant racial stereotypes alone puts it above those two.
Cool, let me revise:

I
II
VII
lmao

Posts: 7738
Joined: February 2012
Location: Boston, Taxachusetts.
TFA was no masterpiece, and as time has gone on I've noticed it more and more. It's really IMO a slightly above average fun blockbuster and not much more. Still, putting it behind Episodes 1 and 2 is quite a stretch. You can try to argue Lucas tried to do something "new and different" and Abrams just coped the fuck out of IV and you might be right, but IMO I and II are executed far too badly for any redemption.

I also seem to recall Armand not feeling that strongly against VII in the past. I remember him ranking things like this before

V
IV
VI
III
VII
I
II

Posts: 9733
Joined: October 2011
Location: Foot of Mt. Belzoni
Time has decayed it. Empty calories.

Star Wars is about a fusion of a myriad of outside sources and concepts, from Ford and Kurosawa to Shakespeare and Marlowe to Campbell, Malory, the Brothers Grimm, documentary footage, Flash Gordon, Herbert, whatever.

When you chuck Lucas in as an influence it implodes upon itself. In the case of this property, I've got more time for ambition, concepts and world building, and no time for anything that offers only a scant sliver of original context. I shouldn't be reminded of another SW film wholesale while watching a different SW film. Themes, motifs, concepts, inversions of scenarios - all fine. But not the broad strokes and movements.

I also loathe the promissory nature of it, which was never a part of how the OT was packaged and is, by extension, a dupe.

Posts: 7738
Joined: February 2012
Location: Boston, Taxachusetts.
What do you mean by "promissory nature"?

Posts: 9733
Joined: October 2011
Location: Foot of Mt. Belzoni
The deliberate withholding of information, with the promise that tune into the sequels to find out stuff!

Yes, you did find out stuff in the sequels of the OT, but they were a surprise not an expectation or demand. As such each of those installments is a full meal. TFA is closer to the Marvel strategem which is fine for those throwaway films.

I also really can't stand the way it's directed. At all. Tableaus pls, not the close-up festival that we get.

That it's revitalised interest in the franchise is fine and dandy and I'm happy for people whose buttons it pushes. It's just not for me, never was, never will be.

Posts: 7738
Joined: February 2012
Location: Boston, Taxachusetts.
ArmandFancypants wrote:The deliberate withholding of information, with the promise that tune into the sequels to find out stuff!
Yeah that annoyed me too, I really don't like the way it ended. That said, somebody could easily argue Empire did the same thing and few hold it against it.
ArmandFancypants wrote: I also really can't stand the way it's directed. At all. Tableaus pls, not the close-up festival that we get.

That it's revitalised interest in the franchise is fine and dandy and I'm happy for people whose buttons it pushes. It's just not for me, never was, never will be.
Fair enough.

Post Reply