I guess she didn't adapt well to the English weather.
katie holmes
Katie's looks with Maggie's acting? Perfect Nolan film.
just use someone else... like Emily Blunt.
Posts: 9827
Joined:
August 2010
She's a hack.Miley Cirus for Rachel would have been perfectZ. Cobb wrote:just use someone else... like Emily Blunt.
Posts: 15900
Joined:
June 2009
im not saying she didnt have weak moments...but i just really disliked how much swagger Maggie gave the role. I dont think that was right for Rachel at all.
Knowing that Maggie and Katie are completely different people, I still have to say that Maggie seemed to shift into a different person. It didn't seem like one Rachel.
you always said she was bad.talli wrote:for all the slack she gets, i think she did pretty great. There are some key important scenes where she delivered the right stuff. For example, the scene at the end was great.
and she has this innocent sweet quality that was necessary for Rachel, that unfortunately, Gyllenhaal just did not have.
Posts: 3861
Joined:
August 2009
I have always felt like Nolan rewrote the character so Maggie could play her better, it does feel like a very different character.Baconboy wrote:Knowing that Maggie and Katie are completely different people, I still have to say that Maggie seemed to shift into a different person. It didn't seem like one Rachel.
That is what I thought he did as well.theweatherman wrote:I have always felt like Nolan rewrote the character so Maggie could play her better, it does feel like a very different character.Baconboy wrote:Knowing that Maggie and Katie are completely different people, I still have to say that Maggie seemed to shift into a different person. It didn't seem like one Rachel.
Like I said there is a reason the joker killed her... just a weak character 
Say Girl
